Hybridization Chain Reaction (HCR) is a method to amplify double-stranded DNA containing many nicks in an enzyme- free manner using microRNA or single-stranded DNA as input. It requires three different templates with a hairpin structure and reacts at 37 ℃. We performed experiments based on existing methods 1.
For more information about the principle of HCR, see Proposed Implementation_Amplification
For more information about the actual experimental procedure of HCR, see Wet Experiments_HCR
Because the expected LoD could not be achieved in 2., changes were made to the experimental conditions.
The paper connects the products of HCR to Cas. Therefore, the concentration of target ssDNA/miRNA and the concentration of Cas target in the amplified product are expected to be correlated. It is expected that long amplified products contain more Cas targets and short amplified products contain fewer Cas targets.
Therefore, we avoided this problem by applying an amplified product with a value close to the “molecular weight" of the peak during attribution. Fortunately, the attribution was not difficult because, in principle, there are only a few amplification products with molecular weights close to the molecular weight of the HCR.
Jia, H.-Y., Zhao, H.-L., Wang, T., Chen, P.-R., Yin, B.-C., & Ye, B.-C. (2022). A programmable and sensitive CRISPR/Cas12a-based MicroRNA detection platform combined with hybridization chain reaction. Biosensors and Bioelectronics, 211, 114382.https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bios.2022.114382
Exponential amplification reaction (EXPAR) is a reaction in which SDA occurs exponentially. After receiving miRNA or ssDNA as input and hybridizing them with template ssDNA, DNA polymerase with strand displacement activity extends to the 5' end of the template to form dsDNA. The restriction enzyme recognition site on the dsDNA is nicked by nickase, and the polymerase recruits to the nicking site to cause strand displacement amplification. If the sequence of ssDNA of the amplified product is the same as the sequence of the input signal, the amplified product plays the same role as the target, and exponential amplification occurs. A 50 ℃ reaction is possible by using Bst 2.0 and Nt.BstNBI. We experimented with existing methods 1.
For more information about the principle of SDA, see Proposed Implementation_Amplification.
For more information about the actual experimental procedure of EXPAR, see Experiments_EXPAR.
When OPC-purified oligo DNA was used, the experimental procedure was the same as in the 1. Preliminary Experiment, but the amplification speed was about five times faster than in the 1.
The left graph shows the fluorescence change in 1. and the right graph shows the fluorescence change when OPC-purified oligo DNA was used in 3. After rearranging the conditions, it was found that Bst 2.0, a polymerase, was purchased again between section 2. and 3., and that only the lot of Bst 2.0 was different between section 1. and 3. Therefore, we concluded that the difference in amplification speed between the two was due to the difference in Bst 2.0 lot. In subsequent experiments, we used the new Bst 2.0 lot and re-examine the response to template / nickase / polymerace concentration.
The LoD was 1 pM when the new lot of Bst 2.0 was used with a polymerase concentration of 0.005 U/µL and nickase concentration of 0.0625 U/µL. EXPAR is an efficient amplification system and is promising to achieve the required amplification efficiency for POIROT within 30 min. On the other hand, EXPAR was shown to be unstable and highly dependent on the lot of the enzyme. The inclusion of EXPAR in the amplification system would reduce the overall robustness of the system. So we were forced to consider a different amplification system.
Carter, J. G., Orueta Iturbe, L., Duprey, J. H. A., Carter, I. R., Southern, C. D., Rana, M., Whalley, C. M., Bosworth, A., Beggs, A. D., Hicks, M. R., & Tucker, J. H. R. (2021). Ultrarapid detection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA using a reverse transcription-free exponential amplification reaction, RTF-EXPAR. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(35), e2100347118. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2100347118
Funakoshi Co., Ltd. (n.d.). dsGreen: Kakusan geru senshoku shiyaku / riaru taimu PCR-yo SYBR®-kei keikō shikiso. https://www.funakoshi.co.jp/contents/67539
Özay, B., Murphy, S. D., Stopps, E. E., Gedeon, T., & McCalla, S. E. (2022). Positive feedback drives a secondary nonlinear product burst during a biphasic DNA amplification reaction. Analyst, 147(20), 4450-4461. https://doi.org/10.1039/D2AN01067D
FASMAC. (n.d.). DNA/RNA jutaku gosei seisei guredo no sentaku ni tsuite. https://fasmac.co.jp/dna_rna_purify_grade
In the following sections, we denote the ssDNA that forms the three-way complex in the first stage as template1 and helper1, the ssDNA that forms the three-way complex in the second stage as template2 and helper2 and the ssDNA product from the first stage of amplification as trigger.
In the fluorescence measurements using both the MB and SYBR Green Ⅰ, no increase in fluorescence intensity dependent on target concentration was observed at all.
However, the lack of amplification even with the MB as described in the paper suggests a need to segmentalize the mechanism further to identify bottlenecks, as well as to optimize the experimental conditions.
We conducted the experiments in two phases, as illustrated in the diagram below.
We designed the mechanism as described above, added SYBR Green Ⅰ, and incubated at 37 ℃ to measure the fluorescence intensity.
When observed using the MB, an increase in fluorescence intensity over time was noted. However, this increase was not dependent on the concentration of the trigger.
In this mechanism, neither the first nor the second phase is functioning effectively, leading us to conclude that it is difficult to use POIROT as an amplification mechanism. Therefore, we considered alternative approaches.
Ying, X., Yu, W., Su, Liu., Jinghua, Y., Hongzhi, W., Yuna, G., & Jiadong, H. (2016).Ultrasensitive and rapid detection of miRNA with three-way junction structure-based trigger-assisted exponential enzymatic amplification. Biosensors and Bioelectronics, 81, 236-241. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bios.2016.02.034
Wang, C., & Yang, C. J. (2013). Application of molecular beacons in real-time PCR. In M. D. Teintze (Ed.), Molecular Beacons (pp. 45-59). Springer.https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-39109-5_3
ThisAmp is a modified version of the SDA reaction that incorporates the TWJ structure, and it was reported by Lee et al. 1.
For more information about the principle of TWJ and SDA, see Proposed Implementation_Amplification
For more information about the actual experimental procedure of ThisAmp, see Experiments_ThisAmp
The reaction mechanism of ThisAmp:
ThisAmp had a LoD of 100 pM after optimization. This reaction is characterized by the fact that it proceeds at a constant 55 ℃ and requires no temperature change. ThisAmp is useful in that it can form a TWJ and amplify miRNAs, but it is not suitable for miRNA amplification due to its long target length (59 mer) . In addition, since the target, template, and helper must be annealed before adding the enzyme, it is difficult to connect other amplification mechanisms before this reaction considering a one-pot amplification system. Furthermore, since the main amplification product is dsDNA, it would also be difficult to connect other amplification mechanisms behind this reaction.
Lee, S., Jang, H., Kim, H. Y., & Park, H. G. (2020). Three-way junction-induced isothermal amplification for nucleic acid detection. Biosensors and Bioelectronics, 147, 111762. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bios.2019.111762
TWJ-Toehold is a variant of the SDA reaction that introduces the TWJ structure and was reported by Chen et al. 1.
For more information about the principle of TWJ and SDA, see Proposed Implementation_Amplification.
For more information about the actual experimental procedure of TWJ-Toehold, see Experiments_ TWJ-Toehold.
TWJ-Toehold had the LoD of 10 pM. This reaction is useful in that it can form a TWJ and amplify without the need for temperature changes at a constant 55 ℃, and has a detection limit 10^1 orders lower than ThisAmp, but the target is 51 mer long, making it unsuitable for miRNA amplification. In addition, since the target, template, and helper must be annealed before the enzyme is added, it is difficult to connect other amplification mechanisms before this reaction in a one-pot amplification system. Furthermore, since the main amplification product is dsDNA, it would also be difficult to connect other amplification mechanisms behind this reaction.
Chen, M., Jiang, X., Hu, Q., Long, J., He, J., Wu, Y., Wu, Z., Niu, Y., Jing, C., & Yang, X. (2024). Toehold-Containing Three-Way Junction-Initiated Multiple Exponential Amplification and CRISPR/Cas14a Assistant Magnetic Separation Enhanced Visual Detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. ACS Sensors, 9(1), 62–72. https://doi.org/10.1021/acssensors.3c01622
TWJ-2cycle is a variant of the SDA reaction that introduces the TWJ structure and was reported by Zhang et al. 1. This method is expected to have high specificity.
For more information about the principle of TWJ and SDA, see Proposed Implementation Amplification.
The series of reactions proceed at an isothermal temperature of 37 ℃
In the paper, Klenow (exo-) DNA Polymerase was used as the polymerase, but we used Bst LF, whose amplification at 37 ℃ has been confirmed in previous experiments.
No amplification was observed at all.
Polymerase 0.063 U/µL and Nickase 0.12 U/µL or Polymerase 0.063 U/µL and Nickase 0.16 U/µL showed good S/N ratios; the latter showed higher values than the former in S/N ratio, but the amplification curve shows no significant difference between them. Since enzymes are expensive and it is desirable to reduce the amount used, we considered 0.063 U/μL for Polymerase and 0.12 U/μL for Nickase to be optimal and decided to use these conditions for future experiments.
Similar sequences are known to exist in hsa-let-7b, the target miRNA of this system, and are named hsa-let-7a, hsa-let-7c, hsa-let-7d,..., hsa-let-7i. In the reference [1], specificity has been studied for these series. We evaluated the specificity of the let-7 series plus an originally designed single nucleotide variant of let-7b.
In TWJ-SDA, the amplification curve is similar to that of Negative Control except for target in the let-7 series. This indicates that TWJ-SDA can ensure high specificity compared to NJ, that is, when the three-way complex is not formed.
The fluorescence intensity at 40 min after the start of the reaction, including the error range, is evaluated in the figure below (error bars indicate standard error).
For subsets of the let-7 series, no significant differences in fluorescence intensity were observed in TWJ compared to NC except for let-7b.
In NJ, let-7c was not significantly different from let-7b, and let-7e and let-7i showed significantly higher fluorescence intensity than NC.
Single nucleotide mutants showed no significant difference from the Negative Control except for mutants at 1 mer, 9 mer, and 11 mer from the 5' end.
Mutations from 5' end to 1 mer and 9 mer showed significantly higher fluorescence intensity after 40 min compared to NC, especially the mutation from 5' end to 1 mer, which was not significantly different from the perfect-match let-7b.
Thus, it was confirmed that the specificity changed depending on the position of the mutation.
For a discussion of the reasons for this, see engineering, Model_Specificity.
The use of TWJ showed extremely high specificity compared to NJ, indicating that TWJ-SDA is an extremely promising system to ensure the target specificity required for POIROT. However, the amplification efficiency of TWJ-SDA alone is considered insufficient for amplification of extremely low concentrations of miRNA in a few tens of minutes. Therefore, it is necessary to combine the system with other mechanisms to increase amplification efficiency.
Qing, Z., Feng, C.,Feng, X., Yongxi, Z., & Chunhai, F. (2014). Target-Triggered Three-Way Junction Structure and Polymerase/Nicking Enzyme Synergetic Isothermal Quadratic DNA Machine for Highly Specific, One-Step, and Rapid MicroRNA Detection at Attomolar Level. Anal. Chem. 2014, 86, 16, 8098-8105. https://doi.org/10.1021/ac501038r
New England Biolabs. (n.d.). Bst DNA polymerase, large fragment. https://www.neb.com/ja-jp/products/m0275-bst-dna-polymerase-large-fragment
New England Biolabs. (n.d.). Nt.BbvCI (nicking endonuclease). https://www.neb.com/ja-jp/products/r0632-ntbbvci
In SDA using TWJ, amplification can be performed by changing the template and helper sequences to target any miRNA in principle. However, it has been suggested that the stability of the TWJ portion changes the specificity and sensitivity DS1.
Designing appropriate template and helper sequences according to the miRNA sequence to establish desired amplification is essential for the versatility of POIROT. Amplification experiments with various sequences were performed to obtain parameters for sequence design by Dry Lab.
We designed a number of templates and helpers to amplify hsa-miR-10b-5p, hsa-miR-375, and hsa-miR-30d-5p (referred to as Biomarker 1, 2, and 3 in this order), which have been reported as biomarkers for glaucoma, and conducted experiments.
More information about biomaker miRNA, see Proposed Implementation_biomarker
We then changed the hybridization length of the template and helper to 5-7 bp.
We then measured the changes in fluorescence intensity under various target concentrations.
The experiments were performed using SYBR Green Ⅰ under the conditions tuned in TWJ-2cycle for the type and concentration of polymerase and nickase.
In the following, the helper for Biomarker n, which hybridizes with template and m bp, is referred to as helper n-m.
As for the difference in the fluorescence curve in response to the target concentration, we were able to clearly distinguish between NC and 1 pM or higher for biomarker1 when helper1-7 was used. Furthermore, looking at the slope in the first linear amplification section, it was confirmed that there was a positive correlation with target concentration in the region of 1 pM - 100 pM target concentration. In other words, the amplification rate of TWJ-SDA is considered to be determined by the target concentration.
However, for biomarker 2 and 3, there was no helper that showed a clear target concentration-dependent amplification rate.
The stability of the TWJ complex is related not only to the hybridization region between template and helper, but also to the region where the target and template hybridize. It will be necessary to conduct experiments by changing the hybridization length of the template and target to find the optimal TWJ structure.
For biomarker 1, 2, and 3, the hybridize lengths of template and target were 10, 11, and 12 bp, and the hybridize lengths of helper and template were 5, 6, 7, and 8 bp, respectively.
In the following, if the hybridize length of template and target is 10 bp, the hybridize length of helper and template is 5 bp, for instance, this experiment condition will be referred to as 10-5.
The larger this ratio, the more clearly the target concentration can be distinguished.For Biomarker 1, when the condition was 12-5, that is, when the hybridize length between template and target was 12 bp, and the hybridize length between template and helper was 5 bp, the ratio was the largest.
Similarly, it was concluded that 10-5 or 12-7 for Biomarker2 and 12-6 for Biomarker3 would be optimal.
For more detailed analysis, see Model_Sequencedesign
Qing, Z., Feng, C.,Feng, X., Yongxi, Z., & Chunhai, F. (2014). Target-Triggered Three-Way Junction Structure and Polymerase/Nicking Enzyme Synergetic Isothermal Quadratic DNA Machine for Highly Specific, One-Step, and Rapid MicroRNA Detection at Attomolar Level. Anal. Chem. 2014, 86, 16, 8098-8105. https://doi.org/10.1021/ac501038r
Strand Displacement Amplification (SDA) is a method to produce a large amount of ssDNA by using DNA polymerase with strand displacement activity and nickase, which recognizes dsDNA and puts a nick on one of the strands. We focused on the system 1 developed by Dr. Komiya at JAMSTEC. This system is a multi-step combination of SDA reactions to amplify ssDNA. The SDA reaction is originally subject to amplification even in negative control, but in this system, negative control is suppressed by various innovations. We call this system “multistep-SDA” and conducted experiments.
For more information about the principle of multistep-SDA, see Proposed Implementation_Amplification
For more information about the actual experimental procedure of multistep-SDA, see Experiments_Multistep-SDA
In the paper, no amplification of NCs was observed in the 3step-SDA reaction, but in our experiment, amplification of NCs was observed by connecting multiple steps of SDA. We asked Dr. Komiya, the author of the paper and our extra adviser, for tips. He told us that it is important that the 3' ends of template DNA are chemically modified with carboxytetramethylrhodamine (TAMRA) .
By using a template with TAMRA modification at the 3' end to link multiple stages of SDA, it was confirmed that target amplification could be efficiently achieved while NC amplification was suppressed. The increase in amplification efficiency by increasing the number of stages was also confirmed. However, amplification was observed within 200 min only when the target concentration was 100 pM or higher, and this mechanism cannot be used in POIROT, which aims for detection in the fM order. Therefore, Multistep-SDA must be combined with other amplification mechanisms.
Multistep-SDA is a system that uses short nucleic acids as input, and in principle, any sequence of nucleic acids can be amplified by changing the template sequence. In addition, this system is characterized by the fact that it proceeds at 37 ºC without the need for temperature changes. Furthermore, it is also possible to amplify dsDNA by changing the template sequence and eliminating the nicking site. Therefore, multistep-SDA is a useful system that can be easily connected to other amplification methods that proceed at 37 °C and to the CRISPR-Cas system that targets dsDNA.
Komiya, K., Noda, C. & Yamamura, M. (2024). Characterization of Cascaded DNA Generation Reaction for Amplifying DNA Signal.New Gener. Comput. 42, 237-252. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00354-024-00249-2
New England Biolabs. (2013). Why did you remove DTT from your restriction enzyme buffers? https://www.neb.com/ja-jp/faqs/2013/02/28/why-did-you-remove-dtt-from-your-restriction-enzyme-buffers
none
none
none