Overview
The Polypropylene Extruder and Parts Library provide a solution to issues that all labs face:
Plastic Waste
From pipette tips to culture plates to sample tubes, single use plastic waste is rampant in synthetic biology labs. Due to the nature of synthetic biology work, single use plastic is required to maintain sterility and minimize consumables costs. However, the environmental and financial costs of plastic consumables add up. Biologically-oriented research labs produce an estimated combined total of 12 billion pounds of plastic waste per year globally1, which costs individual labs tens of thousands of dollars to dispose of each year2. Additionally, most of this waste isn’t recycled due to biological contamination risks3, exacerbating research labs’ negative environmental impacts. The Polypropylene Extruder reduces lab plastic waste by converting it into high-value polypropylene 3D printer filament. Combined with the Parts Library, this project contributes to the establishment of a circular life cycle for polypropylene consumables in the lab.
Equipment Issues
The hardware in the Parts Library is designed to complement and retrofit lab equipment to make lab work more ergonomic and efficient and reduce the need to purchase new equipment. Check out the Parts Library to see how each part achieves this!
Ergonomics
Up to 60% of laboratory researchers suffer from musculoskeletal disorders due to poor ergonomics in common repetitive laboratory activities including capping and decapping sample tubes, pipetting, and vortexing4.
The following parts improve ergonomics:
- Microcentrifuge Tube Decapper Thumbpiece
- Multi-Centrifuge Tube Decapper
- Vortex Tube Holder
- Single Pipette Holder
Inefficiency
Does your lab have a drawer full of different sized sample tube holders? A pipette stand that is only half full? Most laboratory equipment is not adjustable, which results in multiple variations of the equipment being required or the equipment being larger than necessary. As a result, this equipment cannot be easily moved around and takes up space in labs that are often already crowded.
The following parts improve efficiency:
- Analytical Balance Tube Holder
- Microcentrifuge Tube Decapper Thumbpiece
- Multi-MicroCentrifuge Tube Decapper
- Cell Phone Microscope Holder
- Single Pipette Holder
- Incubator Plate Holder
- Test Tube Holder
- Single Pipette Holder
- Attachment to Salad Spinner Centrifuge
Lack of Specialized Equipment
Oftentimes, laboratory equipment is too expensive to buy multiple versions to accommodate different uses, such as centrifuges for different tube sizes. In other cases, the specific equipment required for a researcher’s needs isn’t available at all. This has led to a rising interest in “DIY hardware” in life science laboratories5.
The following parts provide low cost alternatives to specialized equipment:
- Salad Spinner Centrifuge
- Gel Electrophoresis Comb
High Costs
Laboratories are often limited by budgetary constraints, making purchasing and upgrading equipment infeasible for smaller labs and self-funded groups like iGEM teams.
The Parts Library reduces the need to purchase new equipment and invest in costly upgrades by providing accessories that improve existing equipment for only the cost of printing!
The disposal of plastic waste costs individual labs thousands of dollars to dispose of each year2. Although reusable alternatives exist, these options have higher upfront costs and are labour intensive due to their need for cleaning.
The Polypropylene Extruder converts plastic waste into high-value 3D printer filament, turning a source of expense into a source of revenue!
How it Works
iGEM Guelph has developed a method of valorizing plastic lab waste in a way that minimizes environmental and financial burdens while also improving the efficiency and ergonomics of lab work. The lab-scale Polypropylene Extruder converts plastic lab waste into high-value 3D printer filament and the Parts Library provides a variety of low cost 3D-printable equipment accessories to make lab work more efficient and ergonomic.
The Polypropylene Extruder
The Polypropylene Extruder is small enough to fit on a lab bench, easy to assemble, and less expensive than commercially available equipment, making it a great tool for lab groups on a budget like iGEM teams.
The Engineering Cycle
In building our plastic extruder, we followed the iGEM engineering cycle, which involves the stages of Design, Build, Test, and Learn.
- Design: We began by designing the extruder with a focus on processing polypropylene, considering its melting point and material properties. Key design elements included precise temperature control and an extrusion chamber tailored to handle the properties of polypropylene effectively.
- Build: After finalizing the design, we proceeded to build the extruder. This involved assembling the heating elements, extrusion chamber, and motorized components. We utilized 3D-printed parts and off-the-shelf components to construct a functional prototype.
- Test: Once built, we ran multiple tests to assess the extruder’s performance, focusing on extrusion consistency, temperature regulation, and the quality of the recycled plastic output. Initial tests revealed issues with temperature fluctuations and motor torque, which required further adjustments.
- Learn: Through these tests, we learned that maintaining a stable extrusion temperature was critical for consistent performance. This insight led us to redesign certain components, such as the heating system, and improve motor control to enhance the machine’s reliability.
By iterating through this cycle, we were able to refine the extruder's performance, making it both efficient and adaptable for plastic recycling purposes.
The Construction Manual
Section 1: Parts List
Part | Quantity | Total Price ($) |
---|---|---|
Extruder
|
1 | 200 |
Mica Band Heaters | 2 | 23.11 |
8mm-14mm Shaft Coupler | 1 | 24.85 |
Max6675 K-Type thermocouple | 1 | 10.99 |
Cooling Fans | 2 | 9.59 |
Mineral Wool Insulation | 1 | ~10 |
Reversible High Torque DC Motor | 1 | 22.59 |
Wood Frame
|
1 1 |
~18 ~8 |
Spool Supports | 1 | 5.48 |
Batteries (9V) | 4 | 9.98 |
Toggle Switches | 4 | 20.33 |
Arduino Uno Kit
|
1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 ~20 |
53.92 |
Hardware
|
~20 ~10 6 |
~14 |
Total: | 430.84 |
Section 2: Extruder Assembly
Step 1: The Screw, Barrel & Nozzle Assembly
- Instructions: Slide the screw into the barrel and tighten the nozzle on the front. Place the barrel on the support to level.
- Function: The extruder screw has a unique design which forces plastic through the barrel as it’s heating while applying mechanical pressure which melts the plastic as it’s forced through the nozzle to create filament.
Step 2: The Heaters
- Instructions: Slide both band heaters onto the extruder barrel so they are on either side of the first thermocouple inserts, and tightly fasten them to the barrel.
- Function: The heaters are 35mm mica band heaters, designed to fit around our extruder barrel. They operate on 110V AC and deliver 380W.
Step 3: The Insulation
- Instructions: Place the semi-cylindrical pieces of mineral wool around the extruder barrel, and wrap in heat resistant aluminum insulation. Additionally, fasten the extruder barrel to the frame using the U-bolt.
- Function: The Insulation can withstand high temperatures and traps the heat from the band heaters for safety purposes and to retain heat and minimize energy consumption.
Step 4: The Coupler
- Instructions: Tightly fasten the coupler to the shaft of the screw.
- Function: The coupler connects the motor shaft to the screw allowing us to rotate the screw. It has a 14mm side to connect to the screw and an 8mm side to connect the motor. This is a flexible coupler which allows for minor misalignment between the two shafts.
Step 5: The Motor
- Instructions: Slide the motor shaft into the coupler and tighten. Attach the motor to the 3D printed support and brackets to secure it in place.
- Function: The motor in use is a reversible high torque gear reduced DC motor. The motor operates on 24V and rotates at 20-30 rpm.
Step 6: The Hopper
- Instructions: Screw the hopper assembly onto the opening in the extruder barrel.
- Function: The hopper funnels the plastic into the extruder.
Step 7: The Cooling Fans
- Instructions: Secure both cooling fans to the base with the use of brackets.
- Function: The cooling fans help to cool the filament as it exits the nozzle.
Step 8: The Stepper Motor
- Instructions: Attach the wooden supports to the base with the brackets. Attach the 3D printed stepper motor support to the wooden supports, and attach the Stepper motor to the 3D printed support.
- Function: The stepper motor allows for accurate control over the rotation speed of the spool. The stepper motor is a BY J-48.
Step 9: The Spool
- Instructions: Place the filament holder supports on the base, and place the spool on the filament holders supports. Insert the 3D printed motor spool coupler into the spool and attach to the stepper motor.
- Function: The spool controlled by the stepper motor stores and neatly winds the extruded filament as it’s produced.
Step 10: The toggle switches & potentiometers
- Instructions: Fasten the 4 switches and potentiometers to the control panel.
- Function: The toggle switches manage power to the heaters, fans, motor, and stepper motor, while the potentiometers adjust the speed of the motor and stepper motor. This allows for manual operation of the apparatus, ensuring both safety and control.
Section 3: Control and Automation
Step 1: The Heaters
- Circuit Diagram & Code:
- Function: The heating circuit utilizes an arduino to mimic a conventional PID temperature controller. The thermocouple is the key sensing element, which detects the temperature in the extruder barrel, and relays this information to the arduino. The arduino controls the input to a single channel relay module, which acts as a switch turning on and off the connection of the two heaters in parallel and the AC power source. The relay module turns off once the temperature set-point is exceeded, to maintain a constant temperature. In the case of polypropylene we are using a set-point of 170°C to exceed the melting point of 160°C.
Step 2: The Motor
- Circuit Diagram:
- Function: This circuit controls the speed of the motor to allow for fine tuning of the extrusion rate, and filament diameter with the use of a potentiometer and a NPN transistor. The potentiometer outputs a variable voltage to the base of the NPN transistor, which varies the current supplied to the motor.
Step 3: The Stepper Motor
- Circuit Diagram & Code:
- Function: This circuit controls the speed of the stepper motor to achieve consistent winding of filament around the spool. The output of the potentiometer is connected to an analog input pin on the arduino. The arduino correlates the input voltage from the potentiometer to a rotation speed of the stepper motor.
Step 4: The Fans
- Circuit Diagram:
- Function: This circuit controls the speed of the motor to allow for fine tuning of the extrusion rate, and filament diameter with the use of a potentiometer and a NPN transistor. The potentiometer outputs a variable voltage to the base of the NPN transistor, which varies the current supplied to the motor.
Why Polypropylene?
Polypropylene is one of the most common plastics used in biology labs because it is autoclavable, non-polar, and resistant to aqueous solutions of salts, acids, and bases, making it ideal for sterile applications in molecular biology work6. Centrifuge and sample tubes, pipette tips, and trays are some of the common consumables made from polypropylene6. Polypropylene is a desirable material for 3D printer filament because it is durable, flexible, and lightweight compared to other plastics7. With a price point ranging from $60 to $120 per kg, polypropylene is a high-value 3D printer filament that costs more than most other varieties7.
Next Steps
In future works, the thermal and mechanical properties of the polypropylene filament should be characterized and the optimization of its printability should be investigated.
Properties of the filament including strength, stiffness, melting temperature, and deformation and flow behaviour are important for assessing its quality and applications. The strength and flexibility of polymers is tested via impact, tensile, and flexural testing in which a standardized sample of the polymer is subjected to hitting, pulling, and bending forces, respectively. The polymer’s response to heat is measured via differential scanning calorimetry and deformation and flow behaviour is measured via rheometry8. This testing should be completed on the recycled polypropylene filament to assess its performance in comparison to new polypropylene filament and identify areas for improvement. Future works could involve the modification of the recycled polypropylene filament using chemical or physical additives to enhance its properties and therefore increase its value.
Due to the high rate of warpage and lack of bed adhesion that polypropylene exhibits, there are several steps that should be done in future work to improve the printability of the filament acquired from the extruder9. The use of scrubbed ultra-high-molecular-weight-polyethylene (UHMWPE) as a printing bed has been shown to provide significant bed adhesion for polypropylene10. The UHMWPE has a similar chemical structure to that of the polypropylene, allowing for significant adhesion10. Furthermore, scrubbing the UHMWPE increases the surface area, allowing for further adhesion between polypropylene and the bed10. Therefore, labs making use of this recycled polypropylene filament should invest in such a printing bed for their printers. Additionally, the printer settings at which the material is printed will affect the final quality of the print8. As such, the use of a design of experiments (DOE) such as the Taguchi method, could aid in optimizing the printer settings to minimize warpage and maximize bed adhesion8.
The Parts Library
The Parts Library is a digital collection of 3D printable parts created to improve the usability and functionality of common lab equipment while reducing costs associated with upgrades. The parts are designed to facilitate and streamline lab activities by improving workflow and retrofitting equipment to make it more ergonomic.
Accessibility and Applicability
All parts are simple and adjustable to satisfy user needs and accommodate a variety of equipment models while being easy to print and use with limited 3D printing experience. Both .SLDPRT and .STL files are provided to make the parts accessible to users with or without the SOLIDWORKS software. .STL files are ready to print and compatible with all 3D printers. .SOLIDWORKS files allow users to modify the parts and see how they are made.
3D printers are becoming increasingly more common in biology labs and are often found in school campuses and community spaces such as libraries, making them easily accessible to small-scale research groups like iGEM teams. Thus, the Parts Library is a valuable tool for research groups regardless of if they own a 3D printer.
User Testing
The parts were designed to solve issues identified by iGEM Guelph’s Wet Lab team and external lab groups, who were consulted via the Accessibility in the Laboratory survey created by the Human Practices team. Throughout multiple iterations of designing and testing, the parts were tested in-lab by iGEM Guelph’s Wet Lab team and improved based on user feedback. Many have been used in iGEM Guelph’s lab with great success throughout this year’s project!
Description: The Microcentrifuge Tube Decapper Thumbpiece allows users to open microcentrifuge tubes with a simple flick of the thumb, improving the ergonomics and efficiency of decapping.
Ergonomic Benefit: Rather than pressing into a small part of the user’s finger, the decapper distributes the force exerted when pressing up on the cap, preventing discomfort.
Efficiency Improvements: The decapper enables users to decap tubes in one hand, leaving the other free for other activities such as pipetting. Due to the shape and rigidity of the decapper, it is much less likely to touch the inside of the microcentrifuge tube than a finger is when manually decapping. This reduces the risk of sample contamination and helps the user maintain sterility during sample preparation.
.STL File: Thumb Centrifuge.STL
.SLDPRT File: Thumb Centrifuge.SLDPRT
Description: The Analytical Balance Tube Holder is an adjustable single-test tube holder that can be used anywhere, but has been optimized for use in small analytical balances. Various improvements have been made to make it more efficient than standard tube racks and standalone holders.
Efficiency Improvements: The tube holder is as small and light as possible to minimize storage space and ensure that it fits on small analytical balance scales and doesn’t exceed their weight capacity. The ability to adjust the holder to a range of tube sizes eliminates the need for multiple holders, saving space. The wide, recessed base of the holder is designed to catch any spilled material to make cleaning easier and prevent the contamination of the scale, which can be difficult to clean thoroughly due to their sensitivity to pressure. The open design allows users to monitor the volume of material added to the tube and easily identify any spilled material.
.STL File: Analytical Balance Holder
.SLDPRT File: Analytical Balance Holder
Description: The Cell Phone Microscope Holder makes taking pictures of samples quick and easy by ensuring that the phone is positioned to get the perfect shot every time with minimal setup, improving the efficiency of data collection during microscopy work.
Efficiency Improvements: With the Cell Phone Microscope Holder no setup is required to perfectly align the shot, reducing the time required to take pictures. The design also allows users to use the microscope through a phone screen, eliminating the risk of eyestrain. The easily accessible design functions as a cheap substitute for expensive microscope screen attachments. The design creates easy collaboration and teaching opportunities by allowing multiple people to look through the microscope at a time.
.STL File: FinaliPhoneMicroscopeHolder.STL
.SLDPRT File: FinaliPhoneMicroscopeHolder.SLDPRT
Description: Salad spinner centrifuges are a cheap DIY alternative to microcentrifuges used in many research labs. Due to the DIY nature of salad spinner centrifuges, the tubes are not very secure and may move while spinning, reducing the effectiveness and consistency of the equipment. The Salad Spinner Centrifuge Attachment secures the tubes in the salad spinner to ensure that the tubes are placed consistently and balanced in the spinner to reduce variability and prevent breakage during use.
.STL File: SaladSpinnerAttatchment
.SLDPRT File: SaladSpinnerAttatchment
Description: The Multi-Microcentrifuge Tube Decapper allows users to open and close multiple microcentrifuge tubes simultaneously, improving the ergonomics and efficiency of decapping and recapping.
Ergonomic Benefits: The decapper prevents discomfort by reducing sample handling and eliminating the need for the user to press on the tube cap during decapping and recapping.
Efficiency Improvements: With the Multi-Microcentrifuge Tube Decapper, users can easily open several tubes, reducing time needed to open the tubes. The quick and efficient uncapping of the tubes ensures minimal exposure to open air and other contaminants.
.STL File: Centrifuge tube decapper (2).STL
.SLDPRT File: Centrifuge tube decapper (2).SLDPRT
Description: The Vortex Tube Holder allows users to use a vortex mixer without the need to hold the tubes, improving accessibility and convenience. To assemble, place the vortex mixer on the base (blue) then slide the appropriate size adjustment cap (green) onto the main cap (gray). Place the tube on the vortex mixer and put the cap on top, then secure the cap to the base using elastic bands (red).
Ergonomic Benefits: With the Vortex Tube Holder, users do not need to hold the tubes, eliminating prolonged exposure to the vibrations from the vortexer and minimizing risk for nerve and musculoskeletal damage.
Efficiency Improvements: The vortex tube holder will eliminate the need for users to stand at the vortexer, allowing them to spend time on other tasks.
.STL File: Vortex Attatchment
.SLDPRT File: Vortex Attatchment
Description: The Single Pipette Holder is a stand designed to securely hold one single or multi-channel pipette.
Ergonomic Benefits: Due to the small size of the holder, users can move it anywhere in the lab and use it during experiments. The holder makes picking up and putting down the pipette more comfortable while keeping the benchtop clean and organized.
Efficiency Improvements: Maximizes space efficiency by taking up only the space that is required for each individual pipette. Reduces the risk of multiple pipettes being knocked from the stand, reducing the amount of recalibration required when accidents occur and thereby maintaining accurate pipette volumes.
.STL File: MicropipetteHolder.STL
.SLDPRT File: MicropipetteHolder.SLDPRT
Description: The Incubator Plate Holder allows users to create an adjustable shelving system in the incubator to organize culture plates, making plates easier to find and retrieve.
Efficiency Improvements: The plate holder makes it easy to store and handle plates in the incubator, improving workflow and reducing the time spent with the incubator door open.
.STL File: Petri Plate Holder
.SLDPRT File: Petri Plate Holder
Description: The Gel Electrophoresis Comb is a convenient low cost alternative to combs sold by equipment suppliers.
Efficiency Benefits: The Gel Electrophoresis Comb is quick to print and has the same functionality as commercially available combs, allowing users to significantly save on time and costs without compromising quality.
.STL File: GelComb.STL
.SLDPRT File: GelComb.SLDPRT
Description: The Test Tube Holder is a single tube holder that allows users to easily read the volume in the tubes.
Efficiency Benefits: The tube holder ensures that the tubes are secure, and is small, improving space efficiency. Its short height allows users to read small volumes of liquid.
.STL File: Test Tube Holder.STL
.SLDPRT File: Test Tube Holder.SLDPRT
Definitions
Differential Scanning Calorimetry: an analytical method to measure the amount of heat released or absorbed by a material during heating and cooling11.
Rheometry: the study of a material’s flow behaviour12.
1. Urbina, M. A., Watts, A. J. R., & Reardon, E. E. (2015). Labs should cut plastic waste too. Nature (London), 528(7583), 479–479. https://doi.org/10.1038/528479c
2. Kilcoyne, J., Bogan, Y., Duffy, C., & Hollowell, T. (2022). Reducing environmental impacts of marine biotoxin monitoring: A laboratory report. PLOS Sustainability and Transformation, 1(3), e0000001-. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pstr.0000001
3. Kuntin, D. (2018). How to... reduce your lab’s plastic waste. The Biologist. https://thebiologist.rsb.org.uk/biologist-features/how-to-reduce-your-lab-s-plastic-waste
4. Park, J.-K., Boyer, J., & Punnett, L. (2022). Biomechanical Exposure to Upper Extremity Musculoskeletal Disorder Risk Factors in Hospital Laboratories. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(1), 499-. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19010499
5. Wenzel, T. (2023). Open hardware: From DIY trend to global transformation in access to laboratory equipment. PLoS Biology, 21(1), e3001931–e3001931. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3001931
6. Eppendorf. (n.d.). White Paper 79: The different plastics used in the laboratory. Eppendorf. https://www.eppendorf.com/product-media/doc/en/6381221/Consumables_White-Paper_079_Tubes-BioBased-Different-Plastics-Used-Laboratory.pdf
7. Simplify3D. (2022). Filament Properties Table. Simplify3D. https://www.simplify3d.com/resources/materials-guide/properties-table/
8. Hassan, M., Pal, A. K., Rodriguez-Uribe, A., Bardelcik, A., Gregori, S., Mohanty, A. K., & Misra, M. (2024). Creating Sustainable Composites from Pyrolyzed Burlap and Ocean-Recycled Plastics using FDM. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, 12(4), 1405–1419. https://doi.org/10.1021/acssuschemeng.3c05031
9. Bachhar, N., Gudadhe, A., Kumar, A., Andrade, P., & Kumaraswamy, G. (2020). 3D printing of semicrystalline polypropylene: towards eliminating warpage of printed objects. Bulletin of Materials Science, 43(1), 171-. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12034-020-02097-4
10. Spoerk, M., Gonzalez-Gutierrez, J., Lichal, C., Cajner, H., Berger, G. R., Schuschnigg, S., Cardon, L., & Holzer, C. (2018). Optimisation of the Adhesion of Polypropylene-Based Materials during Extrusion-Based Additive Manufacturing. Polymers, 10(5), 490-. https://doi.org/10.3390/polym10050490
11. Slough, G. (2022). What is differential scanning calorimetry?. TA Instruments. https://www.tainstruments.com/what-is-differential-scanning-calorimetry/
12. L., Struble, & X., Ji. (2001). Rheology. Handbook of Analytical Techniques in Concrete Science and Technology, 333-367. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-081551437-4.50012-6